Seeing Burma in the News-Media Funhouse Mirror

Through the lens of the prevailing mainstream news media narrative, religious movements tend to be either completely invisible or distorted in order to play up violence and sensationalism. This complaint has appeared countless times in the USC Knight Chair blog, and for that reason the gripe would be tedious if the problem it laments weren’t so damnably persistent.

Take, for example, a pair of recent New York Times stories on current events in Myanmar. Last month the Times warned of an uptick in the anti-Muslim violence that has threatened to derail the country’s democratic and economic reforms. The primary agent of unrest—a monk named Ashin Wirathu—has spun the political capital of the Saffron Revolution into a nationalist crusade against the country’s tiny and largely impoverished Muslim minority.

Yet this week, in a Times article on dramatic changes in Myanmar’s commercial culture, efforts to economically marginalize non-Buddhists through the 969 Campaign received not a single line of analysis. This omission is all the more stunning for the fact that “969” branding is rife among the very peddlers and shopkeepers at the center of the story’s frame.

Obliviousness to the influence of religion on developments in politics, economics and other elements of culture is one aspect of the problem at hand. Another is a narrow focus on religious actors who prosper from conflict. Wirathu’s novelty as a Buddhist bad-boy has inspired breathless headlines like “Burma’s ‘bin Laden of Buddhism’” and “The Face of Buddhist Terror.” To their credit, Global Post (which has produced a series of stories on contemporary Myanmar) and the BBC have complicated this picture, most notably by offering contrary perspectives from monastic 969 dissenters like Kaylar Sa and U Nyarnisara as well as from Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi. But, unfortunately, the narrow frame and distorted focus of the Times pieces come closer to typifying wider coverage of this story.

What’s the present nature of the power-play between Myanmar’s monastic elite and its gradually retiring junta? How are these shifting dynamics affecting the country’s economic and political transformation? Are other dissenting monastic voices speaking out against Wirathu and the 969 Campaign? What are the Dharma-related issues at stake, and how does this complexity play out in lay religious life? It’s not impossible to find answers to these obvious questions in news media coverage from Southeast Asia, but it’s far more difficult than it should be.

Posted in Currents | Comments Off on Seeing Burma in the News-Media Funhouse Mirror

Belfast City Official Responds to Youth Discontent

Belfast

On the River Lagan in Northern Ireland lies Belfast, a city divided by religion and politics dating from the time referred to as “The Troubles.” Although the bloody conflict between Catholics and Protestants ended 15 years ago, political tension stills runs rampant in the city. It reached a violent outburst in January 2013, when the City Council declared it illegal to fly the Union flag on public buildings—an exception to be made only on a pre-selected 16 days a year. “Peace walls,” barriers built to separate neighborhoods, still stand. And many on both sides would like to keep it that way.

Devon Smith reports for the Pulitzer Center on the efforts by Sammy Douglas, a Northern Ireland Assembly member, to ease tensions between Protestant and Catholic youth.

Posted in Europe and North Eurasia, Luce Top News, Main Top News, Reporting, Reporting & Resources, Resources | Comments Off on Belfast City Official Responds to Youth Discontent

Links in the Chain of Trauma

“Leaders have tried to wipe away histories of atrocities by foot-dragging on investigations until new bloodshed dulls memories of the old.”

That line from a New York Times article on Egypt’s military government jumped out at me. Authoritarian regimes know that manipulating collective memory is a key instrument of control, but even democratic societies tinker with remembering and forgetting to pursue ends that have more to do with the exercise of power than the expansion of liberties or the enfranchisement of marginalized people.

Such ambiguity plays beneath the surface of another Times story on divergent European reactions to U.S. spying. In Germany, where recollections of the Gestapo and the Stazi are still vivid, American surveillance has sparked outrage. But in Britain—with the notable exception of the editorial page of the Guardian—reaction to the N.S.A.’s Orwellian activities has been muted, largely because the country has no similar recent history of totalitarianism.

The notion that Western democracy—and its outpost in Israel—is somehow immune to the corruptions of fascism or Stalinism is an implicitly religious idea. This unquestioning sense of fundamental righteousness underlies the ongoing Israeli push for settlements in the West Bank as well as calls for more sanctions against Iran in the U.S. Senate, even though both moves work against these governments’ professed desire for peace and regional stability.

A piece that highlights the interlinking chains of violence, memory and suppression in Egypt is a service to readers as well as an affirmation of the noble idea that journalism is the first draft of history. But an even greater boon would be reportage that draws our attention to the telltale signs—shifts in the interplay between religious rhetoric and political power, for example—that basically decent societies are beginning to lose their way. Prophetic journalism might seem like too much to ask for, but with the traumas of the 20th century still playing out in contemporary geopolitics, any effort to prevent history from repeating itself is worthwhile.

Posted in Currents, Uncategorized | Comments Off on Links in the Chain of Trauma

Muslims, Mormons and Mister Magoo

A New York Times piece on Mormons’ game-changing role in Senate approval of ENDA this week exemplified what smart religion coverage should be and do.  The most prominent political figures in a religious movement that threw its weight behind California’s recently overturned Proposition 8 were indispensible in passing a bill that would ban discrimination against LGBT people in the workplace. How has Mormon thinking on gay rights evolved since 2008? What common political interests link gays and Mormons? How far might the hierarchy of the LDS Church be willing to go in its support for a minority that both challenges and shares some of the core values of Mormonism?

These questions anchor an article that highlights complexity to reveal how a particular religious movement interacts with other cultural forces and changes over time.  Recent international coverage of Islam in the Times, by contrast, allows for little of that complexity or nuance. Muslims in Iran, Pakistan, Somalia, Tunisia and Nigeria are, at best, depicted as helpless victims of intra-religious strife or calculating negotiators trading the threat of violence for economic benefit. At worst, they come across as unreasoning madmen who must be contained at any cost.

This blinkered point of view has to do, in part, with shrinking news budgets. There simply isn’t enough money to support the kind of regular, on-the-ground enterprise reporting that would complicate the two-dimensional picture conveyed by the raft of international stories above. But that economic reality points toward a deeper tension in American news media culture: Given the limited resources that the Times and other legacy institutions are able to devote to reporting outside the U.S., should they focus on conflict (which leaves much of reality outside the frame of the narrative) or devote a greater portion of meager resources to subtler stories (which might cede clicks to outlets that are less interested in tempering sensationalism)?

A recent Knight Chair-University of Akron survey of news consumers suggests that audiences are eager for complexity. That kind of self-perception is itself ambiguous; perhaps most of those surveyed would simply like to think of themselves as eager for thorough reporting, while the aggregate of their metadata reveals a less sophisticated media palate. In the long run, the Times does no one a service by promoting a near-sighted reporting culture when it comes to religion coverage. Mister Magoo always managed to avoid stepping off a precipice at the wrong time. In our own shifting landscape, we have to depend on news media, rather than blind luck, to keep us from plunging into the void.

Posted in Currents | Comments Off on Muslims, Mormons and Mister Magoo

Peacemakers gather under heavy guard to confront Nigeria’s Christian-Muslim violence

Padraig O'Malley (C) with a Christian pastor and a Muslim imam in Kaduna, Nigeria. (Allan Leonard/GlobalPost)

Padraig O’Malley (C) with a Christian pastor and a Muslim imam in Kaduna, Nigeria. (Allan Leonard/GlobalPost)

 

Soldiers with automatic weapons flanked our convoy and armored personnel carriers guarded the entrance as we arrived at the opening of a peace conference here.

This city, which has been a flashpoint in Nigeria’s ongoing violence among Christians and Muslims and a counter-insurgency campaign against Islamic militants, is serving as host of the 4th International Conference of the Forum for Cities in Transition.

The gathering brings together some 200 delegates and observers from divided societies around the world, including Lebanon, Kosovo, Northern Ireland, Iraq, Israel and Palestine, who’ve come to share lessons learned on strategies of reconciliation and the arduous process of restoring trust in conflict-torn countries.

GlobalPost editor Charles Sennott reports from an interfaith peace conference in Kaduna, Nigeria.

 

Posted in Africa and Middle East, Luce Top News, Main Top News, Reporting, Reporting & Resources, Resources | Comments Off on Peacemakers gather under heavy guard to confront Nigeria’s Christian-Muslim violence

Turkey: A Day in Fatih

Young women break for prayer and dodge a maintenance team, in one of Fatih's many mosques. Image by Jenna Krajeski. Turkey, 2013.

Young women break for prayer and dodge a maintenance team, in one of Fatih’s many mosques. Image by Jenna Krajeski. Turkey, 2013.

On weekday mornings the Fatih branch of Tekbir, a popular Istanbul-based Islamic fashion company, is quiet. One Thursday in early October Fatima, a Tekbir sales person, milled around the racks of clothes, smoothing down dress sleeves and tidying stacks of blouses, fluffing hanging displays of brightly colored scarves all stamped with the label’s name. Like her colleagues, Fatima wears a long, sea foam green coat buttoned up to her neck, a matching patterned headscarf, and a small gold name tag. She is an observant Muslim, at home in Fatih, a conservative neighborhood on the Golden Horn where she has been working for the past year and a half.

The Pulitzer Center’s Jenna Krajesk reports from Fatih, a conservative Muslim neighborhood in Istanbul, following the protests that shook Turkey in May.

Posted in Europe and North Eurasia, Luce Top News, Main Top News, Reporting, Reporting & Resources, Resources | Comments Off on Turkey: A Day in Fatih

LAT: Begging the Question on Child Marriage

An October 30 article in the Los Angeles Times reports on a UN population study on child marriage and frames the problem as a primarily economic one. The 7.3 million babies born each year to girls under the age of 18 are cast as drags on developing economies since young mothers who might otherwise be in the workforce are at home caring for children. Add to that the expense of healthcare associated with adolescent pregnancies and child marriage can cost a poor country like Uganda 30 percent of its GDP.

What’s to be done? The article quotes  UN Population Fund executive director Babatunde Osotimehin as to what shouldn’t be done — namely, blaming the victim — but provides no hint to a possible solution other than to say it should be “holistic.”

Fortunately, the study itself offers up a number of approaches to reduce the number of child brides — including involving religious leaders in the effort. “Motherhood in Childhood” makes it clear that child marriage is primarily a problem borne of poverty, lack of education and cultural tradition, but notes that religion is often used as a pretext for the practice. Religious leaders of all faiths officiate child marriages, rendering them sacrosanct. For this reason, the UN, UNICEF, and the International Center for Research on Women have all called upon faith leaders to speak out.

In September, UNICEF  Nepal released a video featuring Hindu, Buddhist, Christian and Muslim leaders denouncing child marriage. Eleven percent of Nepalese girls are married before the age of 14 and 29 percent are married before age 18. In the PSA, Dr. Chintamani Yogi, the founder of the Hindu Vidya Peeth School in Nepal and an activist for women’s and children’s welfare, is unequivocal in his condemnation and, unlike the LA Times, is very clear about what needs to be done and who needs to do it.  Says Dr. Yogi:  “The holy books revere marriage as a holy union and a part of culture. Someone who does not send their children to school and prevents them from gaining an education is not a parent — but an enemy.”

Posted in Currents | Comments Off on LAT: Begging the Question on Child Marriage

International Town Hall: Egypt and the Struggle for Democracy

Egypt

America Abroad explores what lies ahead for Egypt’s fragile democracy in this international town hall discussion connecting audiences and a panel of experts in Los Angeles and Cairo.

The conversation explored the Muslim Brotherhood’s future in Egyptian politics; the role of Islam in politics and public life; what the military’s recent government takeover means for Egypt’s fragile democracy; and how Americans perceive recent developments in Egypt.

The town hall was co-hosted by America Abroad’s Madeleine Brand and ONTV host Ramy Radwan. Radwan is the co-presenter of Sabah ON, ONTV’s live morning show, covering news and public affairs in Egypt.

Los Angeles panelists:

  • Sarah Eltantawi – Post-Doctoral Fellow in Arab Studies at the University of California Berkeley, specializing in political Islam in the contemporary Muslim world; and
  • Maha Awadi – an Egyptian-American host, producer and media consultant who lived and worked in Egypt for 14 years.

Cairo panelist:

  • Ambassador Raouf Saad – Former Assistant Foreign Minister of Egypt.

The town hall is airing as the October, 2013 episode of America Abroad and on ONTV in Egypt.

 

Posted in Africa and Middle East, Luce Top News, Main Top News, Reporting, Reporting & Resources, Resources | Comments Off on International Town Hall: Egypt and the Struggle for Democracy

Tibet: A Wave of Self-Immolations

self-immolation

More than 100 Tibetans have self-immolated since 2011 — including monks and nuns, farmers and nomads, adults and teenagers. The Chinese government blames the “The Dalai Lama Clique.” Meanwhile, Tibetans hope that the self-immolations will bring global awareness to China’s policies towards Tibet.

Jeffrey Bartholet looks at the human and political dimensions of the burnings — their meaning, their possible impact, and the battle over who controls the narrative. He also explores the peculiar history of self-immolation, and the related debate among some Tibetan Buddhists about whether they constitute acceptable or unacceptable violence.

 

Posted in Asia and Oceania, Luce Top News, Main Top News, Reporting, Reporting & Resources, Resources | Comments Off on Tibet: A Wave of Self-Immolations

God, Government Power and the GOP

German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Tea Party hero Sen. Ted Cruz would likely agree with the proposition that the U.S. government under President Barack Obama has become an unholy behemoth, arrogating power and trampling on liberties it’s supposed to protect. But for Cruz and his congressional fellow travelers, the danger manifests mainly as Obamacare and similar initiatives that inspire “dependency.” Merkel and other geopolitical allies, however, see the threat in the broad sweep of U.S. spying programs.

This contrast is starkly apparent in today’s New York Times, which leads with stories about new GOP strategies to undo the Affordable Care Act and growing anger over reports of U.S. surveillance of friendly states.  In some ways it’s puzzling that the latter story isn’t also a rallying cry for the Tea Party Movement—Edward Snowden’s revelations suggest that the N.S.A. is disinclined to heed either citizenship or national boundaries in its voracious consumption of digital data, which should provoke anyone, at home or abroad, who harbors a gripe against Really Big Government.

Tom Edsall’s summary of recent surveys of rank-and-file Republicans suggests several reasons for this lopsided angle on what counts as overreaching by the Executive Branch. Among the overlapping constituencies of libertarians and religious conservatives who compose the Tea Party Movement—and who collectively account for the overwhelming majority of Republican voters—concerns about race, immigration, cultural influence and constraints on capitalism all crystalize in the opposition to Obamacare. If anything, the fear and isolationism that underlie these concerns tend to abet rather than challenge the trends supporting the growth of the surveillance state.

I’d argue that even deeper still lies the Reformation belief in the Two Kingdoms—a worldly dominion where God’s surrogates rule by means of the sword and a spiritual realm where salvation occurs through God’s intervention. In other words, the notion that the business of government must be limited to the exercise of force is the flipside of the idea that human societies can only be redeemed through the work of divine grace.

Given this bit of context, tolerance for surveillance and strident opposition to a program aimed at national social improvement isn’t so surprising in a political movement with deep roots in America’s Protestant religious consciousness.

All of this is more than a merely academic concern for the genealogy of contemporary American politics. As is apparent in the pair of headlines leading the news in today’s Times, the priorities—and omissions—of the GOP’s Tea Party faction shape events well beyond our national borders. Analyzing the religious impulses that animate the movement is essential to understanding its likely trajectory, but the Times and other mainstream news media remain timid about making these connections. That must change.

Posted in Currents, Uncategorized | Comments Off on God, Government Power and the GOP